Lucrezia CafeMenusWine ListingRavesContact LucreziaGeneral InfoLucrezia Gift CardsCatering in ChestertonHistory of LucreziaEventsItalian Recipes
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Lucreziacafe on Twitter
Follow Us on FacebookFollow Good2GoLucrezia on Twitter
Good to Go logo

Fax us your Big Box Lunch order today!



  • Deli
  • Wine Shop and
  • Wine of the Month Club
  • Specialty Market
  • Tasting Emporium
    • Extra Virgin Olive Oils
    • Specialty Flavored Oils
    • Balsamic Vinegars
  • Boxed Lunches
  • Gift Ideas

Spring Hours

Sunday: Closed
Monday through Friday 10:00am to 6:00pm
Saturday: 10am – 4pm


420 S. Calumet
Chesterton, IN 46304
Phone: (219) 926-EVOO (3866)
Fax: (219) 926-2244


May Cheese of the Month

  • Chipotle Gouda from Boar's Head
  • Made from 100% Whole Cow's Milk, Chipotle Spices and Jalapeno Peppers
  • We would discribe the flavor as smokey, nutty, delicious, with just the right amount of heat.
  • Make a Chipotle Gouda Cheese Log, stop in the deli and pick up the receipe for this easy appetizer!
  • Pair with our new Boar's Head Chipotle Chicken Breast for a Bold savory Sandwich or make a chop salad. 
  • This is cheese that can be grated or sliced. 
  • On Sale in May  Take $1.00 off 8oz wedge pre cut pieces.   Regular: $8.00  Sale: $7.00


WINE OF THE MONTH CLUB!  Join our new Wine Of The Month Club by calling 219-926-3866 or stopping in at the Deli or at our restaurants either Crown Point or Chesterton location.  Each month 2 wines will be chosen that represent excellent quality and exceptional value.  Every wine we choose will have been scored 85 or higher by the Wine Spectator, Wine Enthusiast, Wine Advocate or Robert Parker and sampled and approved by our tasting panel! 


Trecce dell"orto, Calamarata, Orecchiette just to name a few. 

Mancini Fried Red Peppers, Great for Sandwiches, paninis, salads, soups, sauces!

Squid Ink Black Spaghetti Pasta from Pirro.  Imagine how cool this will look with white sauce and some scallops!

Quadratini Bite Size Wafer Cookies in Dark Chocolate, Lemon and Cappuccino are all natural and perfect with a cup of coffee.

Handcrafted Caramels from Becky's Blissful Bakery.  They come in three 100% Organic Flavors.  Margarita, Sangria and Salted Beer & Pretzel Flavor.  Notice a theme?  We thought they would be a great treat with a glass of wine or a cold beer.

"Live-A-Little" Organgic, Sulfite Free, Fair Traded Wines from South Africa in 3 Varietals.  Really Ravishing Red, Rather Revealing Rose, and Wildly Wicked White.  We think the names speak for the wine.  They are fun, delicious and very inexpensive!

Black Truffle Bread Sticks.  These are delicious and very essential to your pantry especially impressive when company arrives unexpected.

Tipperary Irish Cheddar Cheese.  We have to hand it to the irish on this one, they know what they are doing...unbelievable cheddar!

P"Tit Basque Cheese from France.  Delicious Sheep's Milk Cheese!  Wonderful to snak on or add to salads.

Boar's Head Low Sodium Golden Chicken is our newest find.  It tastes like fried chicken but is 42% lower in sodium.  We love it!!

Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Hojiblanca EVOO Best Of Show!
  From Australia, this year's award winning EVOO has a ripe fruity aroma with a strong presence of grass and apple. 

Milanese Gremolata EVOO.. Gremplata is a traditional Italian Herb condiment consisting of fresh lemon zest, minced garlic, italian flat leaf parsely and a hint of mint. 

Roasted Walnut Oil...Our handcrafted Walnut Oil is made in Saumur France strictly following a 150 year old traditional method.  Slowly roasted to perfection, expeller-pressed and lightly filtered.
Athenolia EVOO...The Olives for this oil were hand picked in the Peloponnese and cold pressed to produce this fabulous oil.  It is the crown jewel of Greek Olive oils, loaded with flavor!  Perfect for dipping and salads.

Cobrancosa Early Harvest EVOO from Portuguese Varietals.  It begins with a unique, herbaceous, green aroma followed by savory, ripe olive with lingering pepper.  Rich and smooth, well balanced.  This is unusual & extremely rare.  


Balsamic Vinegar

Strawberry Balsamic....Had just arrived.  Both sweet and tart, our strawberry balsamic vinegar is the result of adding pure and natural strawberry essence to 12 year aged balsamic vinegar.  Can be used both as a vinegar and condiment on dessert dished such as friut medleys and icecream.

Raspberry Balsamic Vinegar...This thick, rich perfectly balanced balsamic vinegar oozes with the natural flavor of fresh, ripe raspberries.  Both sweet and tart, it is perfect tossed with mixed greens and a little feta or goat cheese.

Cranberry Pear...Crisp, tart and boasts a deep rose blush.  Fruity, complex bouquet that shines in a multitude of culinary applications.  Use to dress vegetable and fruit salads, as a marinade for pork, a glaze for poultry with gelatin for delicious fruit aspic, or even in a mixed drink!